I have recently been making some substitutions to characters in the story I have been working on. I was looking in Titanic: Women and Children First for information on Frank John William Goldsmith, who has relatives on this board. In the book, it says that Frankie and his mother escaped the sinking on Collapsible "C." However, there were certain possible factual discrepancies I found in the book. Was there a human barrier surrounding both Collapsible "C" and Collapsible "D"? Or was Collapsible "D" the only boat that a human barrier was formed around? If it was only "D", then it leads to the idea that the Goldsmith's indeed did leave on Collapsible "D". Any help on this subject would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.