Jim said: "It was very, very dark and the submerged boat was invisible to all on board it. Lightoller said his boat was "bottom-up" and Bride knew for sure, his boat was bottom up. In my book, that makes 2 boats bottom up."
No it doesn't. It simply means that person A knew his boat was bottom up, and person B knew that his boat was bottom up. If there was only one boat that was bottom up, then person A and person B got onto the same bottom up boat. This is not a case of 1 plus 1 equaling 2; it's a case of faulty logic on the part of one of our esteemed members.
No it doesn't. It simply means that person A knew his boat was bottom up, and person B knew that his boat was bottom up. If there was only one boat that was bottom up, then person A and person B got onto the same bottom up boat. This is not a case of 1 plus 1 equaling 2; it's a case of faulty logic on the part of one of our esteemed members.
Last edited: