Could Titanic have survived the collision if she had a double hull?

  • Thread starter Saberius Prime Gaming
  • Start date
Steven Christian

Steven Christian

Member
As Mr. Standart and others have said we know the doors were open and the portholes were opened. What made it even worse on the Britannic was that the nurses had opened up the lower row portholes to ventilate the wards because of the weather. When the ship developed her extreme list those portholes were exposed to the sea pretty much at once unlike Titanic from what I could gather. But comparing Titanic to Britannic is kind of an apples vrs oranges thing. Lots of different factors in play. According to the gentleman's article below they did try to close the doors for the boiler rooms but for some unknown reason they failed. You can read the article yourself if interested. But in case your not I'll post a pic from it. It's one I don't recall ever seeing before. From the SS VESTRIS sinking in 1928. Cheers.
3288883 orig
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cam Houseman
Mike Spooner

Mike Spooner

Member
While on the subject of could or not survived. IF Titanic had the same steering gear as Lusitania or Mauretania had, would she missed the iceberg?
 
Jim Currie

Jim Currie

Senior Member
Could Titanic have survived the collision if she had a double-hull? If no other changes were made other then having the extra hull?

Or would it be worse as all the water would be trapped on the starboard side with no way to even the ship out? I'm not sure where the trim tanks where located.
If the volume of the spaces between the outer and inner hulls was the same as it was in the double bottoms, then she would have survived. As she would have done, if only her double bottoms had been breached.
 
Top