Did most Survivors see a top down or Bottom up fracture during the break up? What's the evidence against and for both?

[Cam Houseman]

Hi y'all. I've been seeing lately people talking about a Bottom-down break up. But, most shows/documentaries show a top down break, and in sinking simulations, they always show a top down break. Does that mean most Titanic historians agree its was a top-down break up?

What's the evidence against and for a top down and bottom up Break up?

Thanks, have a great evening (or morning, depending on your timezone)

 

[Mark Baber]

The details of of the break-up is the subject of numerous other threads. There's no need for another one.