Keira Knightly doesn't hold a candle to Kate Winslet - but then I may be prejudiced because her character ****** Captain Jack Sparrow in DEAD MAN'S CHEST. Kate - on the other hand - continues to create fascinating characters. I adored her in FINDING NEVERLAND and THE ETERNAL SUNSHINE OF THE SPOTLESS MIND. I also loved her in IRIS and was pleased that Judi Dench was in that as well (so was Jim Broadbent) as Dame Judi is another favorite. I love it that Kate is down to earth, although friends of mine who met Keira and the other pirates on the red carpet at Disneyland last month said she was very sweet to all the fans. I guess she needed to be as a pre-emptive to any backlash that might result after people see the sequel.