Mystery of Bert's Titanic Postcard


Encyclopedia Titanica

Staff member
Member
Sep 1, 1996
5,063
125
513
titanic-postcard-picture_L.jpg

Postcard message contains clues to the identity of an unknown crewman....
 

Dave Gittins

Member
Mar 16, 2000
5,055
338
433
I'll throw a spanner in the works. Why assume the postcard is from somebody on Titanic? Anybody could buy a postcard. Notice that he is sending 2/6 for Easter. Easter fell well before Titanic sailed, so when was the card sent? Where are the address and stamp?
 

William Oakes

Member
Mar 6, 2020
216
89
73
Could It be Bert Pittman?
He would have been on board at that time getting ready for the maiden voyage.
Just my 2 cents...
 

Dave Gittins

Member
Mar 16, 2000
5,055
338
433
No way! Herbert Pitman was an educated officer. The card is from a semi-literate man, who has been doing some unpleasant drudgery. As I say, why assume the card is from somebody on Titanic?

The card itself is one of many rushed into print in 1912, with Olympic standing in for Titanic and the common error about her displacement.
 

William Oakes

Member
Mar 6, 2020
216
89
73
I'm so sorry to enflame your passions....
It was just a thought.
Sorry to have started a 3rd world war with my feeble 2 cents.
 

Jane55

Member
Aug 20, 2020
24
25
13
I took the remark 'Didn't have time to write before' as he didn't have time to write before Easter. I'm going to assume he bought the postcard on the ship as he was so busy working on board and he was sleeping on board for the night, and why buy a postcard from a ship he wasn't working and sailing on? I'm also going to assume he wasn't married, or at least the postcard doesn't sound like he was writing to a wife, maybe Mother and Father and sisters? Was Bert Pittman married? Wish we knew the address this postcard was found in. I do like a mystery. :)
 

William Oakes

Member
Mar 6, 2020
216
89
73
I'll throw a spanner in the works. Why assume the postcard is from somebody on Titanic? Anybody could buy a postcard. Notice that he is sending 2/6 for Easter. Easter fell well before Titanic sailed, so when was the card sent? Where are the address and stamp?
I don't see how you read all of that into a postcard.
Semi-litterate?
Drudgery?
Some ginormous assumptions from a few lines on a postcard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

Jane55

Member
Aug 20, 2020
24
25
13
Ok, I've cracked it. I think it's Albert Hector Crisp. He married a widow called Florence late 1911 and she had two little girls from her previous marriage, (P/O was for 'the girls'). He joined the ship in Belfast on 01/04/1912, before Easter, which was on 07/04/1912, so P/O WOULD have gotten to them on time. He gave his address as 37 Macnaughten Rd, Bitterne, Southampton. I've looked at the 1911 census and Florence was at that address, not just with her daughters, but her parents and brother and sister as well. Her Mother's name is Mary (Name on the postcard is Mary, not May). So, that would explain why he started his message to 'All' and not just his wife's name. It was a bit of a housefull. Plus, when he asks if Mary was happy, that could be because Florence was pregnant with Alberts baby, so could be why he asks if she's happy. Unfortunately he died and his body was never found. So anyway, I'm convinced it's him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
May 18, 2020
1
0
11
.
It is strikingly odd that the tear goes through the ships profile on the post card in almost the same area of the ship were the breakup occurred in real life.
Considering the value of this postcard I dont think a person with post wreck discovery knowledge would have torn it in half much less tried to repair it afterword's with scotch tape. The yellowing discoloration to the damage and the repair tape indicates that it occurred at a time when it was widely believed that the ship sank in one piece, which leads one to believe that it wasn't done by someone before the wreck was discovered to demonstrate or prove a point about the sinking and break up.
Rationally I dont think it was an ominous premonition just a bizarre coincidence. After dismissing any intentional motive, however the thought that the random location and the type of damage to the ship profile in mimicking what really happened feel disturbingly eerie to make you wonder why the hairs on the back of your neck are now standing up.
 

Similar threads

Similar threads