I believe you are incorrect - his daughter Rose Caroline was my grand-mother. She married William Rogers, in Oswestry, Shropshire in 1919. She had 4 chlidren: Joan (1922 - my mother), William, Thelma and Roy. As well as my grand-mother's testimony we have copies of the marriage certificate. His other children were Walter, Thomas, Helen and Dorothy. We believe Dorothy died prior to 1912 as she was not mentioned in the benefits claim after the tragedy. We have yet to research the others.