Titanic at 2am

Brad Rousse

Member
Nov 27, 2002
170
34
158
34
Prague, Czech Rep.
One of my favorites, along with the 'sequel' "Dusk to Dawn." The way he describes the gradual sinking of the ship and interweaves survivor accounts truly adds to it. The fact Mr. Quinn is a fellow Mainer may also add to the bias. ;-)
 

Bob Godfrey

Member
Nov 22, 2002
6,046
57
208
UK
There's nothing much in the book that will be new to seasoned readers, but where it scores is in creating a very detailed but coherent sequence from the confusion of events in the final stages of the sinking. The illustrations, done by the author, were never intended to be works of art but rather to improve the reader's understanding of the text by showing in particular the progress of flooding. To my mind, they do that rather well. One of the favourites in my collection, and a worthy winner of Michael Tennaro's 'Book of the Year' award for 1997. Highly recommended.
.
 

John Flood

Member
Mar 1, 2004
73
0
76
I thought this was a good book.I felt it gave a good account of the final twenty minutes of the sinking, when things really started to go wrong. The narrative seemed to pretty much match the illustrations. I would recommend it.
 
Nov 12, 2000
682
0
146
Overpricing, MIke B? Why do you say that?

The quality of the art is subjective, of course, it depends on your own personal tastes. Quinn's strength is in architecture, especially the interior of the ship. His depiction of people is weaker, and comes off rather cartoonish.

What Quinn chose to paint is sometimes more important than how he painted it. There are a couple of images that were just chilling, one of the water slowly pooling on the linoleum of a first class corridor, another of water rushing down a third class staircase. The power of those images is very moving.

As Bob said, the real importance of this book, and the reason it won my Book of the Year Award, is that it was one of the first serious attempts to publish a definitive timeline of events during the chaotic last 20 minutes. There is so much conflicting testimony, spread out over many sources. Quinn pulls it all together, and even though one may not agree with all his conclusions, it is still quite an accomplishment.

all the best, Michael (TheManInBlack) T
 
Dec 6, 2000
1,384
1
166
The fact that Paul attempted to put people into the paintings, at critical moments during the flooding/sinking, was very powerful.

I would make a guess that any overpricing of Paul's book is due to scarcity? I know I've never seen it in any regular bookstores, I may have had to buy my copy from the THS, but I'm not sure.

If you like "Titanic at 2 AM", give "From Dusk to Dawn" a shot. More paintings, only this time covering the last day of the Titanic, not just the last 20 minutes.

To get a look at some of Paul's paintings for both of these books, take a look at http://www.fantail.com/ You can also order copies there.

No, I don't get a kickback for saying these things! :)
 
Dec 2, 2000
58,589
379
283
Easley South Carolina
>>I know I've never seen it in any regular bookstores,<<

I got my copy at a second hand bookstore but Amazon.com still offers it HERE. Dusk to Dawn is available HERE. For the reasons expressed here by Bill and TMiB, I think both of these books are worthy additions to your library.
 
Dec 8, 2000
1,289
2
168
I know a number of people who really enjoy the book for the art work, but as per Michael T's comment I value it for the timeline.

Regarding the relatively high price, the book is a large format hardback with full colour illustrations on glossy paper. That, and it's put out by a small press that doesn't have the same opportunities for economies of scale as say Hyperion or Madison Press. All in all, I thought it reasonable for what it was, but it doesn't hurt to check out the used book listings.
 
Nov 26, 2005
671
1
88
Boy I'm glad to see all these good reviews. I just purchased a copy from Amazon.com and it should be here by Tuesday. I'm very much looking forward to reading it.
 
Jan 10, 2006
95
0
76
In my recent book (Rescue of the Third Class on the Titanic)I am critical of Quinn's views in certain respects, but I definitely think his books are worth reading. The illustrations of the ship's decks are great, but those of the break-up are out-dated.

The biggest problem I have with both books is that Quinn only cites little snippets of testimony in support of his account, and these are often taken out of context, or are contradicted by other testimony that is left out. The story he paints of the last twenty minutes, in particular, should be taken with a grain of salt.


DG
 
May 3, 2002
800
24
148
57
Wellington, New Zealand
A friend loaned me this book and I was impressed by the way Quinn approached his subject.
I liked the colour paintings in that they evoked Ken Marschall's work using original perspectives and subjects. I was prepared to overlook the artistic problems of some of them but Like Michael Tannero i was impressed by the staircase waterfall into the steerage Dinning Saloon and the water in the 1st class corridor.

[HINT HINT]
I'd love to see a similar work on the last 18 minutes of the Lusitania's life.

Martin