Titanic film on ITV1

Alex Clark

Alex Clark

Member
Awful. Don't bother with part two. On the other hand there was a very good view of earthshine on the crescent moon tonight. Very nice.
 
J

Jordan Carrington Colby

Member
Sorry everyone, but I have to say this......

I'm really disappointed how people were quick to judge this mini-series based on Episode One. What you people fail to understand is that each of the first three episodes will follow certain characters from their point of view which will be gradually interwoven with each other. Yes, I understand that the characters' storyline's move at a certain pace, but that's reasonable for most television dramas. I'm actually quite disgusted at those who tarnish this mini-series without even watching further episodes to understand what's happening. I've seen episode two and it definitely is a much better improvement. People fail to understand that this is a drama based on the Titanic, not a drama based about the Titanic. I understand that every Titanic enthusiast is quick to judge the mini-series based on historical accuracies. Since when was a an adaption of the Titanic ever so accurate? A Night To Remember had inaccuracies, as did James Cameron's film. The storyline's in the 1958 film moved at a reasonable pace, just like this mini-series.

If you're all going to judge something based upon inaccuracies without focusing on the characters and the events playing out, then it just proves how narrow minded people can be. I'm just really disappointed that people can't appreciate what's been made, and given to them for the 100th Anniversary. I'm shocked that people say that this is disrespectful to those who died. Seriously? How naive can people be! James Cameron's film is being released in 3D for the 100th Anniversary... why don't we watch people die in 3D! Pft. I absolutely enjoyed episode one and two. I thought the script was very well-written, the CGI looked stunning for television, the acting was enjoyable, and the drama was played out very well for its duration. I think it's great that they took a different and unique approach to re-tell the story. If people are going to continue complaining about this, then I highly suggest you write your own screenplay, find a studio who is willing to fund it, then make your own version of events. Because, quite frankly, from what I've read online, you people really need to stop being so critical and ignorant. I really do believe that this mini-series has potential, but people are not giving this a chance to prove itself. You can't judge a book upon its first chapter! You just have to get to the end to decide whether you liked it or not.

And Paul, if you're going to spell 'Downton', 'Downtown', then you clearly have no idea what you're speaking about.....
 
P

Paul Lee

Member
A simple slip of the fingers and you lambast me?

If Fellowes produces stuff that he says is accurate and isn't, then he should be taken to task, like James Cameron. Fellowes claims his version
is accurate and will be close to the disaster, but from what I have seen, its little more than either a retread of old debunked fables (the 3rd class gates)
or introduces serious new errors. If he claims to be a "Titanorak" then he should know about the mistakes.

As for Titanic 3D, lets be under no illusions: it is not to honour the dead, but to make more money from the disaster.
 
J

Jordan Carrington Colby

Member
I apologize if I came off a bit rude, but I'm in shock that people have begun to tarnish this mini-series based on episode one!! I think it's the media that have sporn that folklore about Julian Fellowes stating this his mini-series will be 'closer' to the truth. He did mention that he will portray Murdoch in a less negative way and that he will focus on the lives of the passengers of that night. I thought the portrayl of the Allison family was a nice touch.. I've seen a trailer to episode four and their death will be graphic for television. I just think people should at least give this a chance as episode two definitely makes sense of it all. Fellowes wrote the script, but he didn't design the sets. I've seen your website, and, though I agree with some of them, I still would rather enjoy what's been made and given to us in honor of the 100th anniversary. I understand that the storyline's move at a certain pace, but didn't A Night To Remember use the same format? It didn't drag on like James Cameron's film, and as tempting as it sounds to wait 2 hours to see the ship sink... it's very unflattering. Julian Fellowes has written that the ship will begin to sink 3 times, and only in the final episode will we see the big finish. I think people will be impressed with the final moments in episode four. I think it's an interesting and unique way to tell the story. I understand that people have their opinions, but after what I've read online, this is beyond ridiculous.

p.s. it's belfast that the Titanic is docked in the opening scene. It all makes sense in episode two.
 
Alex Clark

Alex Clark

Member
Actually I think Mr. Colby makes a fair point. I shall continue to watch this series and see how it goes.
 
P

Paul Lee

Member
If the Titanic is docked in Belfast in the opening scene, then why are the sheds, even down to the paint scheme, doors, windows, design the same as the Southampton scene?

I am glad you toned down your response. I think that people who purport to present the truth to a wider audience have a responsibility, whether this be tinkering with people's behaviour or even things like the set design.
 
J

Jordan Carrington Colby

Member
Alex, Episode Two will air on Sunday, April 1 in the UK. I noticed Global (Canada) heavily edited episode one to fit screen time. I was shocked when I discovered what was missing. I know episode one is floating around on YouTube, but that's not the full episode!! I wouldn't be defending this mini-series if I didn't think it had promise and it does... just give it time.

Paul, I think you'd better ask the Crew that..... as I said: Fellowes wrote it. He didn't create the sets, or the CGI effects.
 
R

Russell Friesen

Member
Hmmm... looks like I missed the premiere on Global here in Canada. I see, however, that ABC in the United States has the broadcast rights and I presume will be broadcasting it soon. Does anybody know when this will happen?

I'm willing to give it a chance despite what is being said about it. After all, it couldn't possibly be worse than the 1996 miniseries with George C. Scott and Catherine Zeta-Jones! ;o)

Edit: I did some Googling and will answer my own question. Looks like it will commence April 14th on ABC.
 
Last edited:
James Martindale

James Martindale

Member
I shook my head when I watched the "keep away" scene with the book in the servants dining saloon.

However, because I still have the hope that things might improve with future episodes (and maybe because I'm a bit of a glutton for punishment), I'll probably watch through it.
 
J

Jake Peterson

Member
So, this will be on in the U.S. on Apr 14th on ABC then? Guess I'll keep an eye out for it. Wonder why they're showing it in the U.K before the U.S.?
 
R

Russell Friesen

Member
Hi Jake, I can understand it airing in the UK before the USA because the series was produced in the UK, but why it aired in Canada 4 days before it aired in the UK is what I don't get. Since the Canadian version is chopped to fit a time slot, looks like I'll be watching ABC the same time you will!
 
J

Jake Peterson

Member
Also, will they show it all at once here, or show it as individual episodes as it sounds like they are doing there?

Sounds like I'll be in for an inaccurate retelling of the Titanic saga.
 
R

Russell Friesen

Member
The first three parts will be shown on April 14th back to back, and the conclusion shown on the 15th. See this link for preview:

ABC.com - Titanic - Home
 
Last edited:
Top