Titanic vs. Lusitania's Funnels


Kyle Naber

Member
Oct 5, 2016
1,066
551
188
20
One of the more popular theories as to why Titanic's first funnel collapsed was due to base compression from the water pressure difference during the beginning of the plunge. I know that the funnels were made of a relatively thin metal, almost the same thickness as a thick cardboard. However, when we look at the sinking of the Lusitania, none of her funnels buckled in on themselves and went down intact. In fact, many of her survivors said that they could see all four of them go down virtually horizontally. Is this simply because of the design and materials used, or perhaps did something else occur in Titanic's case?
 

robert warren

Member
Feb 19, 2016
185
64
73
I think maybe the Lusitania was better built. She was designed as an auxillary cruiser so maybe that concept influenced her funnel construction as well.If you look at what happened to the Britannic, her funnels fell off as was plunging down too. Maybe funnel construction Q.C. wasn't a Harland and Wolf strongpoint?Who knows? Of course I don't. I'm just throwing this out there.
 

Similar threads

Similar threads