Just an aside, but, if I were Smith, I think I might very well have looked that way myself that night!
Otherwise - I agree that the 'ANTR Smith' was probably the best. I also happen to think that the ANTR Andrews was "right on the button".
As for Ismay - I feel that there was a motive to make him look 'the yutz' (lovely woid, Bill!) in ANTR - rightly or wrongly.
Best looker for the part? Well, there's this little Swedish gal in steerage in ............