The Last of the Last

How Masabumi Hosono's Night was Forgotten

Titanica!

The Last of the Last

The nightmare of near-death became a nightmare of survival for the only Japanese passenger on Titanic.

As the Carpathia steamed towards New York with the survivors from the Titanic, some of them, sensing that they had witnessed a momentous event, began to make notes of what they had experienced.ii Two of them, Colonel Gracie and Lawrence Beesley, would soon publish detailed, carefully researched accounts of the disaster, which have since seen several re-issues. Both men held forth on the qualities of the 'Anglo-Saxon' or the 'Teutonic' race, to which they attributed the conduct of the men and women in the last hours of the Titanic.iii With such an attitude commonly prevailing, it is small wonder that no one on the Carpathia showed any interest in an Asian writing down his own experience of the previous night in a letter to his wife. He wrote it on a piece of Titanic stationery, on which he had begun a letter in English on 10 April, only to discard it.iv To most witnesses of the disaster the Asian survivors were "Chinamen, "Japs" or "Filipinos" (they cared not which), and they had saved themselves as "stowaways" or had jumped into lifeboats against the officers' orders.v And of course they travelled third class.

Three times Hosono was told off for trying to get through to the second­ class section of the decks. The first time he started to obey, until he realized that no-one else was moving in the same direction; the second time he explained that he was a second-class passenger, the third time he ignored the seaman’'s words and slipped past. He joined the commotion on deck and observed that the officers were letting only women and children in the lifeboats, threatening the men with pistols. As he saw four boats launched, he tried to resign himself to his fate. But then someone shouted, "room for two more," and at that moment a man jumped into the boat. Hosono saw his chance and followed him: 'Fortunately the men in charge were taken up with something else and did not pay much attention. Besides, it was dark, and so they would not have seen who was a man and who a woman.'vi He had indeed passed unnoticed, and the other people in the boat later described him as a "Japanese stowaway."vii He was set to row like the other male passenger, an Armenian.viii

Like many survivors, Hosono believed he had got into the last boat; however, he almost certainly survived in boat 10, generally believed to have left the Titanic at 1:20 a.m. as the third boat on the port side, although one other witness claims that it was the last boat.ix It may have been the only boat he could see at the time, but his assertion probably says more about his frame of mind than the actual situation. In fact, Hosono's report adds little to our knowledge of events in those final moments before the Titanic sank and immediately after. In some points it resembles Beesley's; Hosono too mentions the calmness of the crowd on the doomed ship, his shock when the Titanic sank and his relief and gratitude when he was saved. He observed the re-shuffling of passengers in the boats in mid-Atlantic, as Fifth Officer Lowe prepared to row to the rescue of survivors with a few hand-picked men, and suspected it was the benefit of the crew. Like Beesley (pp.186-7), he observed that a high proportion of crew members survived.

Just as Hosono claimed that his boat was the last to leave the Titanic and he himself the last to get into the boat, he also recorded that his boat was the last to be rescued by the Carpathia: “My boat was the last. As before, women took precedence [in leaving the lifeboat – MM], and so I was truly the last of the last.” Again, the accepted story does not agree with his, giving boat 12 and Second Officer Lightoller as the last to reach the Carpathia.x Possibly, Hosono could not see the very last boat in the distance as he climbed aboard, but the significance of his claim lies in the way it illustrates his feelings. In a way, his ordeal was only about to begin, and his journal of the next four days perhaps represents the most fascinating part of his report. On the climactic events of the night followed days of utter tedium; Hosono writes of boredom, of the crowded conditions, the poor food (at least compared to the Titanic) and the bad weather which gave rise to new fears of disaster. Few survivors on the Carpathia could have felt lonelier than Hosono. In Japan, he was an important man. Born in the prefecture of Niigata by the Sea of Japan in 1870, he entered the Ministry of Communications in 1897, after graduating from Tokyo Higher Commercial School and a short spell working for Mitsubishi. In 1906, he graduated from the Russian department of the Tokyo School of Foreign Languages, and in 1910 he was sent to Russia to do research into the Russian railway system. It was on his way back from this trip and after a short stay in London that he boarded the Titanic to return home.xi While on the Titanic, his very presence in second-class and the new clothes he had acquired in London may well have given his fellow passengers some indication of his status, even if their lack of interest and perhaps his poor spoken English kept conversation to a minimum. But on the Carpathia he became just another Asian, whose survival was suspect. He slept in the smoking room, when he could find a space there, but did not like to spend much time in it, because the seamen made fun of him: “Because they are a good-for-nothing band of seamen, anything I say falls of deaf ears.” Only on the last day did he assert himself: “In the smoking room, I talked a little about myself; I showed them a bulldog tenacity and finally gained a bit of respect.”

Once in New York, the lack of interest in his person continued. He made his way to the office of the Mitsui trading company - and what a haven it must have seemed to him! - where old school friends lent him the money to travel home. While he waited for a ship to leave San Francisco he told the Japanese community there his story. Back in Tokyo, he gave an interview to the Yomiuri Newspaper, which also carried a photograph of him with his family, and to a few other newspapers and magazines.xii Then he picked up his life as well as he could.

He lost his post at the Ministry in May 1913, and his career undoubtedly suffered. But the Japanese government could not afford to drop such a highly trained expert, who had just returned from government-sponsored study abroad, so he was soon (June 1913) re-employed, albeit on a contract basis at first, and worked for the Ministry until his death in 1939. He weathered the attacks he, like so many other male survivors, had to endure.xiii Samurai ideals of glorious death played little role in this. By 1912 they were out of fashion anyway; when in September that year General Maresuke Nogi, the hero of Port Arthur in the Russo-Japanese War, followed Emperor Meiji into death, the Japanese reacted with disbelief and shock, and derision as well as respect was expressed.xiv

Besides, no samurai code said anything about “women and children first.” This alleged “rule of the sea” would have been familiar to the Japanese through a different source. Samuel Smiles’ Self Help (1st edition 1859) is not well known in the English speaking world today, but in Smiles’ lifetime it sold over 250, 000 copies and was translated into several languages. In 1870 Masanao Nakamura (1832-1891), scholar, educator and champion of Western thought, translated Self Help into Japanese. Published in 1871, Saikoku risshi hen (A collection of success stories from Western countries) became one of the great bestsellers of the period, said to have sold a million copies. To this day educated Japanese have at least heard of the title and book’s enormous influence on previous generations. The stories, with which Samuel Smiles illustrates the importance of “character – the true gentleman” – include the wreck of the Birkenhead on the coast of Africa in 1852.xv Thanks to the chivalry and courage of the 472 men who went down with the ship, the 166 women and children on board were saved in the lifeboats (at least according to the testimony of Captain Wright, who – rather surprisingly in the circumstances – lived to tell the tale). The story is included in Nakamura’s translation under the heading, “The composed calm of the seamen when an English ship sank on the coast of Africa.”xvi

The opinion of the West mattered greatly to the Japanese in 1912. Their country had come a long way in the last sixty years. Escaping colonization, Japan had since the enforced opening of the country by Commodore Perry in 1853 and the fall of the shoguns in 1868 risen to a modern industrial nation, with a central administration, a parliamentary constitution, a public education system, an efficient infrastructure, a growing economy and a strong military, which had beaten a Western nation, Russia, in 1905. But the Western nations did not welcome Japan playing their own game, and Japan often felt treated as a steerage passenger on the international scene.

Hosono's failure to act as the Anglo-Saxon nations evidently expected their men to act caused embarrassment in Japan, but more because of the Japanese’s acceptance of Western values than because of their own traditions. An ethics textbook for girls in the 1910s condemned Hosono’s behaviour with the telling comment that it disgraced the Japanese. When Hosono’s family expressed concern about this, he replied: “I am alive here and now, what is wrong with that?”xvii Otherwise, apart from the occasional flare-up of indignation, Hosono's countrymen preferred to forget the affair. Hosono himself never spoke of it. After his death his letter was published, and again in 1980, when attempts to locate the wreck aroused new interest in the Titanic.

It took James Cameron’s film in 1997 to bring Hosono's story to a wider, even an international audience. And at last Western Titanic buffs came on the scene. These - according to Biel (pp.177, 270) mostly white men - had so far shown little interest in non-white passengers on the Titanic. Now, some of them fell over themselves to praise the “discovery,” sometimes giving the impression that Hosono’s letter remained unknown for 80 years, when it in fact had previously been published in full in the Japanese press. Commentators invoked “Japanese culture” (culture, as if it were immutable, having taken the place of “race” to explain foreign behaviour) to explain why Hosono's night on the Titanic was forgotten in Japan.xviii No-one asked why it was equally forgotten in the West, where the Titanic enthusiasts painstakingly searched for every little mosaic stone concerning the story of that “Night to Remember.” With the help of someone able to read Japanese, Hosono's trail could so easily have been followed. As a second­class passenger,xix he could be assumed of sufficient social standing to find his way into the newspapers. Sure enough, the Japanese Ambassador in London telegraphed news of Hosono’s survival to Tokyo on the 19th of April, and the newspapers reported it, just as newspapers in many countries today report the fate of their own nationals in a disaster.xx

But as on the Carpathia in April 1912, so in the years that followed the disaster, no Westerner had much interest in the lone Japanese. Hosono's story, written as a private letter and not for public consumption, vividly illustrates how human reactions to a tragedy resemble each other across cultures and races. Nevertheless, Western perceptions of the Japanese still focus on differences and on that which separates “them” from “us.” Masabumi Hosono’s version of the night may not shed new light on the events in mid Atlantic in April 1912. His fate, however, and that of his story say a great deal about Western attitudes towards Japan then and now.

© Margaret Mehl

i I thank my colleague Takahisa Furukawa, professor at Yokohama City University and descendant of Hosono Masabumi, for sending me copies of Hosono's letter as printed in Sunday Mainichi and of his interview in Yomiuri shinbun. Professor Furukawa has himself published published a short article on Hosono: Taitanikku gô no Nihonjin (The Japanese on the Titanic), in Yûjirô Ôguchi et al., eds, Nihonshi shiwa 3: kindai, kendai (Tokyo: Yamakawa 1994), pp.134-7. ii Colonel Archibald Gracie, Titanic: A Survivor's Story (1913; re-issued Phoenix Mill: Sutton Publishing 1985), p.114; Lawrence Beesley, The Loss of the S.S. Titanic By One of the Survivors (1912; re-issued, Boston: Houghton Mifflin 2000), p.149.
iii Gracie, p. 34; Beesley, p. 51, 193; see also Steven Biel, Down with the Old Canoe: A Cultural History of the Titanic Disaster (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1996), pp.47-8. iv His wife received a letter he wrote on the Titanic on 24 April; see Hideo Hosono, Dasshutsu shita chichi wa hikyô dewa nakatta (My father who escaped was no coward), Sunday Mainichi (14 September 1980), pp. 33-4.
v Walter Lord, A Night to Remember (Harmondsworth: Penguin Books, 1978), p. 138; Biel pp.45­50; 55-7.
vi This and other passages quoted from the printed letter in Sunday Mainichi (Tada hitori no Nihonjinn jôkyaku no sônan, 14 September 1980), pp.30-3; translations by the author. vii Gracie, p.147.
viii Neshan Krekorian; see article by Don Fraser in The Standard (St-Catharines, Ontario, Canada, 10 April 2001; www.geocities.com/Paris/Palais/2230/titanic.html, accessed 24/10/02) and Encyclopedia Titanica: Third Class Passenger: Neshan Krekorian (www.encyclopedia­-titanica.org; accessed 24/10/02).
ix Robin Gardiner and Dan van der Vat, The Riddle of the Titanic: An Astonishing Reassessment of a Disaster that Shook the World (London: Orion, 1995) pp. 140-1.
x Gardiner/van der Vat, p.169.
xi All biographical information on Hosono Masabumi from Ikuhiko Hata, ed., Nihon kingendai jinbutsu rireki jiten (Biographical Dictionary of 3200 Leaders of Modern Japan), (Tokyo: Tokyo University Press, 2002), p.458.
xii Yomiuri shimbun (4 June 1912, morning edition, p.3).
xiii Biel, pp.27-9.
xiv Carol Gluck, Japan's Modern Myths: Ideology in the Late Meiji Period (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1985), pp. 221-6.
xv Samuel Smiles, Self-Help (1859; re-issued London: IEA Health and Welfare Unit, 1996), pp. 248­9.
xvi Samuel Smiles, tr. Masanao Nakamura, Saikoku risshi hen (1874; reissue of the 1927 edition published by Hakubunkan, Tokyo: Kôdansha, 1991); unfortunately, I have not been able to examine the original edition, but apart from modernization of the spelling, the text appears to be unchanged.
xvii Hideo Hosono, p.34.
xviii Frank Gibney Jr, - Mending History: The Descendants of Japan's Sole Titanic Survivor Aim to Clear His Sullied Name, Time 150.19 (10 Novermber 1997);
www.time.com/time/magazine/1997/int/971110/asia.mending histo.html, accessed 10/10/02; in a similar vein: Josef Coleman: Titanic account from sole Japanese survivor sheds light on disaster, Athens Daily News (online version: 20 December 1997);
www.onlineathens.com/1997/122097/1220.a4titanic.html, accessed 21/10/02. Also Don Lynch, quoted in Mimi Lai, “A Case of Injustice: The Story of Masabumi Hosono,” www.geocities.com/Athens/Agora/6683/mhosono.html, accessed 21/10/02. xix His name is listed on the White Star Line’s list, quoted in Lord, A Night to Remember, p. 213, and it is on the list of survivors picked up by the Carpathia, quoted in Gardiner, van der Vat, p. 365.
xx Ôsaka mainichi shibun, (21 April 1912); quoted in Meiji hennenshi hensankai, ed., Shinbun shûsei Meiji hennenshi (Chronological history of Meiji compiled from newspaper), 15 vols. (Tokyo: Zaisei keizai gakukai, 1936) vol.14, p.554.

Related Biographies:

Masabumi Hosono

Related Articles:

The only Japanese passenger on the Titanic

Acknowledgements

Margaret D. Mehl

Comment and discuss

  1. Jan C. Nielsen said:

    disaster has traditionally been a white, Christian cataclysm . . . and is usually approached that way. The "Japanese" who was picked up in the water, was derided on by Officer Lowe, and joked about. Racism and religious intolerance was a problem then, and remains one, today. This... Read full post

  2. avatar

    Phillip Gowan said:

    It is not insignificant that most of Jan Nielsen's posts are characterized by an undercurrent of anger. This conservative, fundamentalist board member is reminded of that little passage of Scripture that says "Anger resteth in the bosom of fools."

  3. Bill Wormstedt said:

    Nice article, Margaret. I will state though, that there is evidence that #10 lifeboat *was* the last of the port aft boats to leave. Both seaman Buley & Evans claimed to have lowered #12 before they left themselves in #10. There is other evidence that #12 was after #14 and #16, though I don't have those details handy. Of course, #10 was not the absolute last lifeboat to leave. All the collapsibles either were launched or floated off later in the sinking.

  4. Randy Bryan Bigham said:

    Margaret, Please be assured that your work is welcomed and appreciated and that any insinuation to the contrary is a lot of hot air. Personally I am fascinated by your subject and applaud you for having the inspiration to shed light on a story little known. Your article on Hosono is first-rate. You have done him proud. As to Jan's criticisms, it's a grossly unfair assessment that the ET board membership is conservative and fundamentalist but it's the intimation of racism that has me outraged. That's totally insupportable. I know a good many of the members here and I can say that, as a... Read full post

  5. avatar

    Michael H. Standart said:

    >>I don't think you'll find many white guys or women sympathetic to your perspective on Hosono, among this conservative, fundamentalist board membership.>The "Japanese" who was picked up in the water, was derided on by Officer Lowe, and joked about.

  6. avatar

    Dave Gittins said:

    Actually, the story of Lowe and the Asian is pure horsefeathers. It was concocted by Charlotte Collyer and/or a reporter. Collyer was never in a position to witness what Lowe did or said while trying to rescue people. Along with all the other passengers, she was removed from Lowe's boat before he went to the rescue. Her story of how she and other women tried to revive the man is pure imagination. Lowe had the usual distaste for 'dagoes' that was common in Britain at the time. Like others that night, Lowe had labelled "Italians" as cowardly trouble-makers. He recanted his remarks about... Read full post

  7. Jeremy Lee said:

    So in this case, were there any racist treatment of Titanic's passengers during the sinking which resulted in them unable to save themselves? If no one saw or heard it, the officer would most probably keep his mouth shut, unlike Lowe.

  8. avatar

    Michael H. Standart said:

    Jeremy, I'm not sure it would have occured to them to give it a lot of thought. Quite a few of the attitudes extant would certainly be offensive by our standards, but back then, these attitudes were accepted as "The way things are." They knew nothing of future sensibilities, had no way of knowing and would have cared less. I went through that article last night. Racism was a factor in the game, but I found it interesting that some of the censure that Mr. Hosono suffered was at the hands of his own people. Racism was not an issue there!

  9. avatar

    Dave Gittins said:

    Oddly enough, statistics show that the percentage of foreign third class passengers surviving was greater than that of the third class English passengers. (The figures are on this site somewhere). Not much evidence of discrimination there. As Michael said, a degree of racism was normal in those days, often under the influence of religion. A famous hymn included this little gem. (I won't swear to this being perfectly accurate) Another famous example of assumed... Read full post

  10. avatar

    Tracy Smith said:

    Randy, You've pefectly summed up my thoughts in the matter about both the article and the people on this board. Thanks for your insightful comments, as usual. Yes, we are a diverse bunch here, and nearly all of us get along together, nevertheless. We all bring something a little different to the group, which I suspect is one of the reasons why this board is such a great success.

  11. avatar

    Kyrila Scully said:

    I haven't read the article yet either, but intend to. I have the utmost respect for Mr. Hosono and the culture he felt he betrayed by surviving (according to one obit I saved - but consider the source - People Magazine). But having met several of the members of this board and corresponding by private mail and phone conversations, I unequivocably second what Randy said! Shame on those who are judgmental of others with whom they have only a cursory acquaintance. Let he/she who is without sin cast the first stone, that's what I always say, quoting someone else's words. I'd say the regular... Read full post

  12. avatar

    Inger Sheil said:

    Lol! "Cutie" strikes again, and once more demonstrates his ignorance of the diversity of the socio/cultural/political spectrum that makes up this board. Because folks don't march in step to his particular brand of bitter revisionism and polemical rhetoric, they are therefore all labelled as 'conservative' and 'fundamentalist.' Your own hidebound, pre-determined position on history, driven by narrow ideology, has determined your approach and tainted your interpretative abilities, and the result (as in your misrepresentation of the incident involving the rescue of a Japanese passenger) is a... Read full post

  13. monica e. hall said:

    Oh dear, I don't know anything of Jan's posting history, so know nothing about undercurrents of anger etc. But I do know a bit about racism, and I think it is often misunderstood. For a start, this is an English-speaking Board, so it is only to be expected that it would be dominated by English speakers. We could probably hear much fascinating information if it were available in, say, Syrian. But that isn't very realistic, so we have to depend on people like Margaret to show an interest and do the translating. The other point I would like to make is that it is quite useless, as others... Read full post

  14. avatar

    Phillip Gowan said:

    So now we know who "Cutie" is! LOL. I had thought it must be Nathan Casteel or some other naughty little child in need of a spanking but guess it was an older "Cutie." Tsk Tsk.

  15. avatar

    Inger Sheil said:

    I've landed finally, Monica But most of my clothes, books and papers are still enjoying their Pacific cruise down under. You raise some excellent points about the nature of racism. Simplistic polemicism rarely covers the complexities of the issue, a view I've had reinforced by living in Asia, studying issues of race at University from an academic standpoint, working on them in politics from a policy standpoint, and again living in a very ethnically diverse area of London. Masabumi Hosono's story provides a good case study of how multi-layered issues of race and... Read full post

    attachment
  16. monica e. hall said:

    Hello Inger, hope the baggage catches up with you. In my experience something will be missing, but I understand it is transported in containers now, so maybe your books and papers will be intact. Here's hoping. Yes, it's interesting, isn't it? There must be quite a few relatives of 3rd class Titanic survivors in the USA who came from the Middle East, eastern Europe and Asia - all of whom must be American citizens who speak English fluently and are probably impeccably middle-class now. And yet, they seem hard to find. They must have stories to tell. Or maybe their grandparents simply... Read full post

  17. Jan C. Nielsen said:

    It’s amazing how my posts have such a “coat-tail” effect. Well, Phil Hind, so I’m “intolerant,” and “angry.” C’mon, are you blind? Look at the rest of these guys. Gowan says I’m “stupid,” and calls me “cutie.” Others tell me I’m “ignorant,” or worse. You tell me, Phil Hind, who really is “angry” and “intolerant”? Your clique, or me? In any event, I fully stand by my position here. Racism may not be excused on the basis that it happened in a different time frame. The people who were the victims of racism didn’t like it... Read full post

  18. avatar

    Inger Sheil said:

    Well, Phil Hind, so I’m “intolerant,” and “angry.” C’mon, are you blind? Look at the rest of these guys. Gowan says I’m “stupid,” and calls me... Read full post

  19. monica e. hall said:

    Speaking of ingnorance, I have no idea what a 'cutie' is... one impression I do get, though, flitting on and off this Board, is how many US attorneys there are, and how very assertive they are. Jan, Tom etc. I suppose the assertiveness comes with the territory. You have to be a fighter to put backbone into vacillating clients, sway juries etc., and I don't mind being cross-examined on messageboards. The ego is a different matter though. The 'coat-tailing' remark, Jan, was definitely a mistake, and a very funny one. Visions of you, the cerebral freedon-fighter striding out ahead, with... Read full post

  20. avatar

    Michael H. Standart said:

    >>It’s amazing how my posts have such a “coat-tail” effect. Well, Phil Hind, so I’m “intolerant,” and “angry.” C’mon, are you blind? Look at the rest of these guys. Gowan says I’m “stupid,” and calls me “cutie.” Others tell me I’m “ignorant,” or worse. You tell me, Phil Hind, who really is “angry” and “intolerant”? Your Titanica clique, or me?>Racism may not be excused on the basis that it happened in a different time frame. The people who were the victims of racism didn’t like it then, and don’t like it today.

View 56 comments...

Leave a comment

Citation

Encyclopedia Titanica (2003) The Last of the Last (Titanica!, ref: #1940, published 25 November 2003, generated 4th June 2020 11:44:50 AM); URL : https://www.encyclopedia-titanica.org/last-of-the-last.html